METHODOLOGY OF SURVEY-DESIGN
FOR INTER-CULTURAL SEXOLOGICAL INVESTIGATIONS
by Yuriy Zharkov
4. Individual behavior and its social regulation
With a view to developing the ecological
model, let us define more exactly the social importance
of sexological texts, using as an example Vatsaani Mallahahi's
Kama Sutra. The translator notes that this is a scientific
and didactic text, and that when studying it, we should
pay special attention, first and foremost, to the distinctive
Ancient-Indian scientific language, which is carefully crafted
with systematic methods for description and enumeration,
and equipped with highly specialized terminology for describing
minute details. The style of Kama Sutra is characterized
by nominative sentences and the use of wish-constructions,
by terminological exactitude and consistency in the use
of previously introduced terms, and by the wide use of synonyms
[8]. The inclination
of Ancient-Indian authors towards the scrupulous classification
of reality is reflected not only in their theoretical discourse,
but also in their artistic productions. They possessed a
system of symbols in which expressive means were linked
to definite objects, states, and virtues. Through these
symbols, they were able to express in art and literature
some unique ideas. A significant part of Ancient-Indian
teaching is concerned with three types, or orientations
of human activity:
Dharma - the totality of social, familial,
and religious obligations, which affect a person's behavior.
Artha - the acquisition and use of material possessions
Kama - the sphere of emotional, sensual life.
This system with three principles, has
helped many generations of Indians to make sense of and
to order their activities in life. At the same time, Dharma,
Artha, and Kama did not always relate so much to different
activities, but rather to different ways of looking at one
and the same activity – evaluating it in ethical, pragmatic,
and hedonistic terms. It was traditionally held that these
three elements should be kept in harmony, so that none of
them had a greater weight than any of the others. If we
compare the Indian categories of Dharma, Artha, and Kama
with the categories (extero-, neo-, and archaeo-) used in
Burn's description of the human psyche we find some striking
parallels (table 1):
Table 1
Parallels between Burn's Categories and
Ancient-Indian philosophy
Structure
of the Psyche (sub-personal
structure)
Personality
Structure
Type of
Activity (meta-personal structure)
Extero-psyche
Parent
Artha
Neo-psyche
Adult
Dharma
Archaeo-psyche
Child
Kama
As Burn stated, the different personality
systems (diag. 1) react differently to stimuli. The extero-psyche
exerts a dogmatic influence, trying to force the other structures
to adopt its judgments. It corresponds to the mental structure
"I am a Parent," comprising the unity of feelings,
manners, and models of behavior similar to those of parents.
This structure manifests itself in various forms of habitual
behavior, and systems of judgment which, though irrational,
appear to the subject as reasoned, and have a proscriptive
character [3].
Diagram 1 – Personality structure according
to Burn
The neo-psyche transforms stimuli into
units of information, analyzing and classifying these elements,
and comparing them to previous experiences. The neo-psyche
corresponds to the mental structure "I am an Adult,"
characterized by the aggregate of feelings, habits, and
models of behavior connected with activity in the real world.
The Adult is realized as an organized, adaptable, and reasonable
person, who forms objective relationships with the outside
world on the basis of real, independent experience.
The archaeo-psyche generates impulsive
reactions not based on fully-formed understanding. The archaeo-psyche
corresponds to the mental structure "I am a Child,"
characterized by the aggregate of feelings, habits, and
models of behavior typical of an individual's childhood.
The Child is distinguished by independence of behavior,
a tendency towards protest, and an inclination towards self-interested
motivations.
In this way, it is possible to use the
categories of structural analysis, intended for the study
of the individual personality, to study the social and meta-personal
structures which regulate an individual's behavior. We can
use these categories to investigate the influence of sexual
morality, ethical norms, taboos, and the specific features
of families and other social groups (table 2).
Table 2
Personality structure in relation to a
society's sexual culture
Sexual Culture
Personality Structure
Personality Structure
in the sexual sphere
Sexual
morality, laws, dogma, and religion
P
-- Parent
P
-- accepts without critical judgment, preaches ethics
and morality
Scientific
knowledge about platonic, erotic, and sexual love,
and about reproduction
A
-- Adult
A
-- becomes acquainted with the world of the opposite
sex, through experience of love and erotic behavior
Art,
depicting sexuality
Ch
-- Child
Ch
-- enjoys and is excited by the sexual and the erotic.
It follows from all this that if a range
of sexological categories are used on a questionnaire form,
and that if the texts reflect ideas of duty, goal-directedness,
and impulsivity, then the questionnaire corresponds to the
ecological model of sexuality.
When designing the questionnaire form,
the sexologist tries to reflect information relevant to
his profession. The text itself, though, must be comprehensible
to a respondent who is not a specialist. In this there is
a certain conflict, which, however, can be resolved if we
use the correct semantic structures to shed light on the
quanta.